Sean Allen, a Cherry Creek High School Student, discusses the controversy surrounding an audio recording he made of his geography teacher expressing political views in the classroom. Mr. Allen later released the tape to the media.

Discussion Questions

1. How do you feel about the teacher's comments, as described by Sean Allen? Do you think the teacher was trying to stimulate discussion? Do you think he was trying to sway the students to his point of view?
2. What reasons does Mr. Allen give for releasing the audio recording to the media? Do you agree with his actions? What role did the media play?
3. Describe your feelings about discussing politics in the classroom. Do you feel such discussions lack multiple viewpoints? Are discussions like the one described in the clip appropriate for classes not directly related to politics, such as geography? Why or why not? Do you think the discussion of current events in general can be helpful in these classes?
4. Do you think the First Amendment protects a teacher's expression of his or her own political views in the classroom setting?
5. Is this expression an example of academic freedom? Do you think a teacher's political expression can serve as a healthy discussion starter?
6. Do you feel that such expressions can lead to open discussions? Why or why not?